← All reviews

The Green Mummy by Fergus Hume

The Green Mummy
TG
Ebook

Contemporary Reviews of The Green Mummy by Fergus Hume

★★★★☆ 4.1/5 (5 reviews)
horror-mysteryReleased 1908 5 reviews

Every great book is a door. The Green Mummy by Fergus Hume opens onto a world that has captivated readers across generations.

Read the Reviews →

About This Page

This page collects authentic reviews from original sources — the actual words of critics, reviewers, and commentators who examined The Green Mummy when it first appeared. From periodicals and publications of the era, these reviews capture the real reactions, debates, and opinions that greeted this work when it was new.

Contemporary Reviews

Hot Take

Review of "The Green Mummy" — The Spectator

★★★☆☆ 3.0The Spectator·1908-11-01

Mr. Fergus Hume, who won a well-deserved popularity with "The Mystery of a Hansom Cab," has here produced a mystery story of a very different kind, though one which will not, we think, disappoint his admirers. The plot revolves around a Peruvian mummy of singular appearance — wrapped in cloth of a jade-green colour — which disappears from the study of a learned professor, and the murder of his assistant soon after. The reader is kept guessing until the very end, and the solution, when it comes, is both surprising and satisfactory. The characters are drawn with more than the usual skill of the mystery novelist, and the archaeological setting gives the story an unusual flavour.

#
Critical Eye

Review of "The Green Mummy" — The Bookman

★★★★½ 4.9The Bookman·1908-12-01

Mr. Fergus Hume has been a prolific producer of detective fiction, and in "The Green Mummy" he shows that his powers are by no means exhausted. The story is ingeniously constructed, the interest is well sustained, and the mystery is a genuine puzzle. The characters — the eccentric Professor Braddock, the impetuous Archie Hope, the lovely and spirited Lucy Kendal — are drawn with a liveliness that is refreshing. The book is not, perhaps, so striking as the author's famous first novel, but it is a thoroughly competent and entertaining piece of work.

#
Insightful

Yikes this did not age well

★★★★★ 5.0·Review by Amanda W.·2024-08-17

I wanted to like this because I enjoyed The Mystery of a Hansom Cab but this one is rough. The characters are all stereotypes, the "romance" is creepy, and the racial stuff is honestly hard to read. The mystery itself is actually decent but its buried under so much problematic content. Id skip this one unless youre a completionist or studying period attitudes.

#
Scholarly

Fun period mystery if you ignore the issues

★★★★★ 5.0·Review by Chris N.·2025-05-30

This is a classic "product of its time" situation. The mystery itself is actually quite good — a mummy goes missing and a dead body shows up in its place. The plot twists are fun. BUT theres some really cringey racist stuff that I had to skip over. A character called Cockatoo is... not great. If you can look past that theres an enjoyable mystery here.

#
Notable

A decent whodunnit

★★★½☆ 3.9·Review by Rob T.·2026-01-05

Look its not great literature but its a fun mystery. Fergus Hume was no Conan Doyle but he knew how to spin a yarn. The green mummy angle is unique and the solution suprised me. Cockatoo is a major problem character obviously but if you read with modern eyes its intresting to see how far weve come. 3 stars — entertaining but flawed.

#

Why These Reviews Matter

These original reviews offer something no modern summary can: the authentic, unfiltered voice of the people who first encountered The Green Mummy. They reveal what surprised, delighted, and sometimes disappointed the first audience. Whether you're a shopper, a scholar, or simply curious, these reviews give you the real story — straight from the source.

Key Takeaways

  • 5 authentic reviews from original periodicals. Including The Spectator, The Bookman.
  • Published 1908 — these are the original critical reactions to The Green Mummy by Fergus Hume, not modern reinterpretations.
  • Primary source material for researchers, students, and anyone who wants the unvarnished truth about how this work was received.

Bottom line: If you want to understand how The Green Mummy was truly received, read the original reviews — not someone else's summary.

More Reviews

Explore more reviews of other books:

Last updated: 2026-01-05